Alright, this really kinda needs to be addressed….
A few points:
1. Math is not emphasized enough, if anything, and students are often taught the wrong way due to ignorance.
2. Math is not just the quadratic formula. Math and logic are, in a lot of ways, the entire basis of our existence. They’re the essence of our communication as individuals.
3. Not a single teacher I ever worked with (including myself) ever said that being good at math is what made you smart, and that you can’t be smart without knowing math. Those who say so are very far and few between.
1. Math isn’t taught correctly in school. No, I don’t mean the new-fangled Common Core “I don’t understand my kid’s arithmetic!” stuff. Math itself is about problem solving and critical thinking. Not memorizing formulas and taking an algorithmic process through things. Students are often told what to do, how to do it, and when to do it, but never given any understanding of why.
For example, I was never taught the derivation of the quadratic formula. Turns out, it’s quite easy.
Often times, the explanations are just plain wrong or begging the question. A common response to “Why can’t you divide by 0?” is “Because 1/x goes to infinity at 0”. Okay….but that doesn’t explain why it can’t be infinity. The graph never shows the entire thing. It’s not definitive in the case of “Well, as you see, the line y = 5+x is 5 at x = 0”. Turns out it’s a simple contradiction and it can be explained to 6th graders. (Suppose we could divide by 0: what’s 0/0? Well:
0/0 = 0 * (1/0) = 0, since anything times 0 is 0.
0/0 = 1, since anything divided by itself is 1.
1 = 0/0 = 0 * (1/0) = 0, and thus, if we could divide by 0, we’d have 0 = 1.)
Just think about it: when was the last time a math teacher of yours had a satisfactory answer to a question?
Not only that, but you are often taught things that really aren’t too applicable in your daily lives. But, this itself is a misdirection, since anyone who goes into any sort of STEM field is going to be using this kind of thing daily, even if indirectly.
What the average person needs in a proper applied math course (basically math NOT for someone who will need college math…well, frankly for everyone including them), would be a course to teach basic accounting, estimating when they need to stop for gas, calculating interest, mental math tricks, etc. But that’s neither here or now.
This breeds contempt and ignorance. By not getting a proper mathematical understanding and proper teaching, people who DON’T grow up to love it the proper way hate it. Math to them is either just a random tool they use or just “Dumb and stupid”. This leads to bad policy towards math and leads to cultural ignorance. This even leads to the false belief that math can only be taught with rote drills.
2. Math is not just the quadratic formula. Math is almost literally everything. Math can be used for almost literally anything. Math and logic together form your entire basis for organizing and understanding your world.
Communicating with people and making implicit understanding of their statements based on context? Inference, which is generally logic. Estimating how far you have until you have to stop for gas again? Math. Figuring out your bills? Math. Cooking? Math. Even the rest of the STEM fields (and some non-stem) are math: Sociology is applied Psychology which is applied Biology which is applied Chemistry which is applied Physics which is applied math. Computer science is math. Your computer is thanks to a long line of mathematicians who figured out the logic necessary to, well, do computational logic. Thank Rear Admiral Grace Hopper, who wrote the first modern compiler. Thank Ada Lovelace, who more or less invented software. Thank Claude Shannon for inventing information theory and proving that electronic switches can model and perform logic.
This is all math.
You name me a topic, and I’ll point you at rigorous math studying that topic.
3. Not even math teachers think you need to know math to be smart. I should know, I used to be one. Math teachers (who aren’t professors of abstract disciplines in a university) know their topic is going to be the stepping stone to another STEM field or related activity. They may think you need math to understand that topic (you do), or that you need math to understand your world (you really do), but they don’t think you need math to be smart. They just think you need math to be less ignorant.
I hated math as a kid. Absolutely hated it with a passion. I sucked at it and barely passed AP Calc my senior year (which I only got into because like 5 other kids moved and I was put into it without my choice). I only started liking it when I was taught properly by good teachers at my university. I only got an appreciation when I was allowed to explore and ask questions and try and understand why things happened. Ultimately, that’s what math is: trying to understand. It’s not the quadratic formula, it’s not the Pythagorean formula, it’s not statistics (obligatory statisticians aren’t real mathematicians joke here), it’s the process of trying to understand something and why it happens.
And, I know for a fact, this is why most people think they’re “too dumb” for math.